What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

If you’re experiencing rough idle in gear, don’t worry – you’re not alone. This is a common problem for many drivers, and there are a few things that you can do to fix it.

In this blog post, we will discuss the causes of rough idle in gear and the steps that you can take to correct it. We’ll also provide some tips on how to prevent rough idleOpens in a new tab.

Rough idle in gear only is caused by bad motor mounts which should normally absorb the vibrations of the engines, faulty spark plugs which can cause an engine misfire, faulty air system (air leaks), or a clogged fuel system.

Key Takeaway

What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

  • Bad motor mounts are not able to hold the engine in place and often cause rough idle. Unfortunately, the only fix for bad motor mounts is replacing them.
  • Faulty spark plugs can cause incorrect combustion cycles by not igniting the air-fuel mixture and can lead to a rough idle. To fix it, you will need to replace the bad spark plugs.
  • Leaks in the air system can cause rough idle by allowing more air in the system than needed. To fix this issue, locate the leak and replace the broken hose.
  • A clogged fuel system can cause a rough idle in gear due to the restricted flow of fuel. Often, using a fuel system cleaner will unclog the fuel system.

What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

If you are reading this article, you are probably experiencing rough idle while your vehicle is in gear but not in park. That would occur at the stoplight, but as soon as you start driving, everything is alright. There are a lot of reasons that cause a rough idle in gear only. Here are the most common:

If your check engine light is on, you want to start with that because that’s gonna point you more specifically to what your issue is. Whether you have a code reader or you go to your local auto parts store that will read your code for free, start there. If you don’t have a check engine light, it means you will have to diagnose the issue yourself.

1. Bad motor mounts

There are a lot of reasons that cause a rough idle in gear only. Here are the most common:

Your engine is held in place by three or four motor mounts. They’re supposed to be made of rubber that isolates the vibration from the engine and the car. When they wear out, they don’t work as well. Every car is going to be a little bit different. But, in general, you’re gonna have engine mounts on both sides on the front and the back of your motor. 

Motor mounts are designed to keep the engine in place while absorbing vibration and noise. Without motor mounts, your engine would rock back and forth whenever you hit the gas pedal, which would make for a very bumpy ride. In addition, all that extra movement would create a lot of noise. Motor mounts help reduce both of these issues, making for a smoother and quieter ride.

There are typically two motor mounts on each side of the engine, and they’re usually made out of rubber or metal. The rubber ones are designed to absorb vibrations, while the metal ones are more focused on keeping the engine in place. Some motor mounts also have hydraulic fluid inside them, which helps dampen even more vibrations.

To kind of get an overall picture of how your engine mounts are doing and whether they’re working properly, you need to get an assistant. Start the vehicle up, and put it in drive with the brake on. When it goes into gear, you watch the motor with the hood open and see if it pitches back and forth. It shouldn’t move very much. If there’s a lot of motion with the engine overall, you know that your mounts are getting old. 

2. Faulty spark plugs

There are a lot of reasons that cause a rough idle in gear only. Here are the most common:

Spark plugs are an essential component of car engines. They create the spark that ignites the air/fuel mixture in the cylinders, providing power to move the vehicle. Spark plugs can become fouled over time due to deposits from oil, fuel, and other contaminants. When this happens, your vehicle will begin to rough idle while in gear and you need to replace the spark plugs.

You need to remove the spark plugs in order to check them. The first step is to disconnect the spark plug wire from the spark plug. Then, use a ratchet or socket to loosen the spark plug. Be sure to use the correct size socket or wrench, as over-tightening can damage the spark plug. Once loosened, unscrew and remove the spark plug from the engine. Clean any debris from the spark plug hole before reinstalling a new spark plug.

When you get the spark plugs out, out you’re looking for the burned-out electrode, too big of a gap, too small of a gap, and corrosion. Cars are meant to have their spark plugs changed at set mileage. Many newer cars have iridium or platinum-tipped spark plugs that can last up to 100,000 miles before they need to be replaced. However, older vehicles with conventional copper spark plugs will likely need new ones every 20,000 to 30,000 miles.

3. Faulty air system (air leaks)

What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

The Air system is what brings the air in and mixes it with the fuel at the right ratio so that your engine runs smoothly and efficiently. If the air system starts leaking, gets dirty, or is contaminated, it can cause your car to start running rough while in gear.

So, when you’re looking at your air system, the air is coming in through the air filter and basically is being distributed all over the place for your engine. The reason an air leak would cause your engine to run rough is that air is entering where the system is not expecting it to. This is all controlled by sensors and if the air is coming in at an odd place, it’s gonna throw off the fuel/air mixture.

The rubber hoses that distribute the fresh air are the ones that usually fail. They are made out of rubber and over time, the rubber hardens and cracks allowing air to escape. If you’re not sure whether or not you have a vacuum leak, there are some signs you can look for. One of the most common signs is an unusual noise coming from the engine bay. This noise is usually caused by air leaking into the engine, and it can be quite noticeable.

Another sign of a vacuum leak is if your car’s idle is unstable. This can be caused by a loss of vacuum in the intake manifold, and it can cause your car to stall or rough idle in gear only.

4. Clogged fuel system

What Causes Rough Idle in Gear Only and How To Fix It

The purpose of the fuel system in cars is to deliver gasoline to the engine. The fuel system has a pump that sucks gasoline out of the tank and pushes it into the carburetor or injectors. From there, it goes into the cylinders where it is combusted. This process happens thousands of times per minute, and it’s what powers your car.

If your fuel system is clogged, it can cause your engine to run roughly in gear only. This is because the engine isn’t getting the proper mixture of air and fuel. As a result, the engine may misfire or run erratically.

Clogged fuel injectors are one of the most common causes of rough idle. When fuel injectors become clogged, they cannot deliver the proper amount of fuel to the engine. This can cause the engine to run lean, which can lead to misfires and a loss of power.

Cleaning the fuel system is important to keep the engine running smoothly. There are a few ways to clean the fuel system, but using a cleaner is the most effective way. Follow these steps to clean the fuel system with a cleaner:

  1. Spend as much fuel as you can and then add fresh fuel.
  2. Get a fuel system cleaner from your local auto part store.
  3. Add the cleaner to the tank and run the engine for 30 minutes. You can either drive the vehicle or let it idle.

You should notice a difference in how your engine runs after you’ve cleaned the fuel system.

Can a Bad Transmission Cause a Rough Idle?

A transmission mount is a support device that helps to keep the transmission in place and limits its movement. The purpose of the transmission mount is to reduce vibration and noise from the engine and transmission, as well as to absorb some of the shocks from shifting gears. The transmission mount also keeps the driveshaft aligned with the differential, which prevents binding and premature wear. In short, the transmission mount serves an important role in keeping your car running smoothly.

A bad transmission mount will not absorb the shocks that occur when shifting gears and will not be able to keep the driveshaft aligned with the differential, which will lead to a rough idle.

A bad transmission mount can cause all sorts of problems for your car. If you notice any of the following signs, you have a bad transmission mount:

One sign that the transmission mount is going bad is if you feel a vibration coming from the engine area when the car is idling. This is caused by the engine being misaligned with the rest of the drivetrain. It can be a serious problem if left unchecked.

Another sign of a bad transmission mount is if your car seems to lurch forward or backward when shifting gearsOpens in a new tab.

Igor Iwanowski

I am a certified Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) mechanic since 2018. I specialize in Brake systems, dashboard warning lights, EGRs, general engine problems, EVAP and Emissions issues.

Recent Posts